Most developers now set carbon targets at the start of a scheme, for operational energy and, increasingly, for embodied carbon. The harder part is carrying them through to letting or sale in a form the market can check. What matters is less how ambitious a target is than how clearly it is defined, briefed and protected.
Over the past decade, carbon has moved from the edge of commercial development to the middle of it. It now shapes how investors and occupiers make decisions. Rent, location and quality still come first, but they increasingly want buildings that support their own commitments too. Decarbonisation has become part of the commercial and planning case for a scheme, not an extra.
That success brings its own challenge. Net zero aims and top sustainability ratings are now routine on major office schemes, so they no longer set a building apart. Buyers and occupiers have started asking to see the evidence. The Better Buildings Partnership has pointed out the gap between design intent and actual performance for years.
For now, a bold target is often what gets a new building noticed, partly because nobody can yet test it. A new building has no record of how it performs in use, and most certifications, energy models and EPCs are based on design rather than measured performance. That is changing. In London, major developments must now report actual energy use for at least five years after completion, and NABERS UK rates buildings on what they use in operation. As in-use data builds up, the claims that keep their value will be the ones that stand up when the building is let or sold. That starts on day one: how the target is set, how it goes into the brief and how it survives delivery.
As Stefan Borowik, partner at G&T, puts it: “When a building is sold, the buyer’s advisers ask to see the proof behind the carbon claims: the energy model, the commissioning records, the metered data. If you can show it, it counts. If you can’t, they treat it as marketing.”
Aim at what the market wants
Carbon performance adds value when it answers something the market needs, or is starting to expect. Different people want different things. Investors want evidence they can report against their own commitments. Occupiers with net zero targets want measured data for their own reporting. A buyer’s advisers want the records. A strategy that satisfies one of them won’t automatically satisfy the others.
2 Finsbury Avenue shows how this works. British Land, Modon and GIC are replacing two outdated 1980s buildings on the Broadgate site with a large, all-electric, office-led scheme. It is targeting BREEAM Outstanding, WELL Platinum, EPC A and NABERS UK 5-star. Embodied carbon has targets of its own, and the project has already brought it well below its original baseline.
Holding all of these together is the hard part, because a decision that helps one target can work against another. As project manager, G&T’s role has been to keep the design team working towards all of them at once, so the sustainability goals are built in through design and construction rather than reconciled at the end.Each of those targets has a purpose. A scheme doesn’t need every credential, but each one it pursues should answer to the market it is aimed at. As certifications become standard in high-quality development, they stop being a differentiator. What sits behind them, and what investors and occupiers will value in the next generation of buildings, matters more.
Treat regulation as the starting point
Planning policy sets the minimum, and in the City of London it is already demanding. The Corporation’s Planning for Sustainability guidance sets NABERS UK targets for both new offices and retrofits, and expects embodied carbon benchmarking and a retrofit-first approach.
So, is decarbonisation a statutory push or a tenant pull? In practice it is both. Regulation sets the floor, and that floor is rising, but occupier and investor demand decides how far beyond it a scheme should go. A scheme briefed only to meet policy may struggle to stand out when it completes. One briefed well beyond what its market values may carry extra cost with no commercial benefit. So set the gap deliberately. Don’t inherit targets from the last scheme or adopt them because everyone else has. Test them against the planning context, the proposition and the people you expect to buy or lease the building.
That raises a harder question, and with viability under so much pressure, a pressing one: how far should you go when further carbon reduction costs more? We look at the balance between carbon, cost and return in the next article in this series.
Put outcomes in the brief
Once the target is set, the brief decides whether it survives. A certification target tells the design team which standard to hit. An outcome-based brief says what the building should actually do, in terms that can be measured. NABERS UK’s Design for Performance process works this way: the developer commits to a target rating at design stage, and performance is checked once the building is running.
A good brief covers operational energy, embodied carbon and the metering and data needed to show how the building performs once it is occupied, including what London’s post-completion reporting will require. A new building has no metered history at completion, so the evidence builds in stages: design-stage commitments, then as-built and commissioning records, then measured use. If metering isn’t in the brief from the start, that last stage can’t happen.
At 2 Finsbury Avenue the team started by asking how much material the building really needed. They questioned structural loads, floor construction and servicing, used standard steel sections instead of bespoke ones, and designed the services around the structure instead of making the structure bigger. Only then did they turn to specification, choosing lower-carbon steel and other materials. Steel beams from the old buildings were reused, and the new frame design was considered on the basis of being able to be taken apart and reused in future. Buying greener materials is only part of the answer, and lower-carbon specifications often carry a cost premium. Some of the best opportunities come from questioning how much material you need in the first place, which can reduce cost and carbon together.
Refurbishment briefs need the same discipline, but you start from what is already there. At Cottons Centre on Tooley Street, a 1980s office being refurbished in phases, G&T instructed detailed validation of the existing MEP systems before the strategy was settled. You can’t decide what to keep, adapt or replace until you know what you have and how it performs. That is what lets you set targets you can actually deliver.
As Max Downes, Associate Director at G&T, says: “Refurbishment is harder to set targets for. The carbon-intensive work of a new build doesn’t apply in the same way, and existing buildings often have a patchwork of systems that have changed over time. Improving operational carbon can mean major interventions that add upfront carbon.”
Hold on to it through delivery
Targets are rarely dropped in one go. They wear away through reasonable decisions: a design revised to recover programme, plant swapped for a cheaper equivalent, a metering strategy cut back. Add them up and the finished building no longer matches the brief.
Carbon needs the same protection as cost and programme. Give each target an owner. Test every proposed change against the carbon brief. Collect the evidence as the job goes on, not at handover.
2 Finsbury Avenue does this. As-built data from each package is collected during construction and checked before it replaces the assumptions in the carbon model. The contractor has said that proving where low-carbon materials came from, between tender and as-built, is one of the harder parts of delivering the strategy. The scheme is currently tracking better than its design-stage figure, and the team is still looking for further savings as the remaining data comes in.
As Anthony Etherington, partner at G&T, says: “Targets cost least when they’re set early. Once the design is fixed, every carbon improvement is a change, and changes cost money.”
It isn’t just an office issue
The same approach applies elsewhere, although what the market values will differ. In housing, carbon performance is felt as comfort and running costs more than as a rating, so the strategy has to answer to what buyers and residents actually care about.
Mixed-use schemes add another option, because some carbon decisions work better at estate level. At Bankside Yards, Native Land has committed the South Bank development to being fossil fuel-free, with a low-temperature energy network shared between buildings and uses. Energy is managed across the estate rather than building by building.
G&T is project manager and employer’s agent on Bankside Yards West, where new homes are being delivered within that wider strategy. The principle is the same as for an office or a refurbishment: decide the outcome early enough to shape the development strategy, not afterwards.
How G&T helps
A competitive low-carbon asset needs carbon, cost and delivery decisions made together.
We support clients in four areas:
- Setting the target: Working with agents, investors and developers, we combine market intelligence, project data and planning requirements to help clients set carbon targets that suit the asset and its market.
- Making it deliverable: We test cost, programme, procurement and technical options, so clients know what is achievable and where early decisions pay off.
- Protecting it through delivery: We put carbon requirements into the brief and test design changes, procurement choices and variations against them, alongside cost and programme.
- Proving it: We make sure the metering, commissioning records and handover information needed to evidence performance are specified in the brief and actually delivered, so the asset is ready for in-use verification and later reporting.
For existing buildings, we start with what is already there. Surveys, technical validation and option appraisal show what can be kept or adapted, where work is needed and what enabling works the business case has to carry.
The competitive asset won’t be the one with the boldest carbon claim. It will be the one whose target suits its market, survives delivery and can be proved once the building is in use.
In the next article in this series, we ask: is the lowest-carbon option always the most competitive?